Meet JoeMcElroy
Your local health insurance expert in Evansville, Indiana — dedicated to helping families find the right coverage since day one.
Our Core Values
Family First Partners was built on a simple belief: every family deserves access to quality health insurance with honest, personalized guidance. No upselling, no fine print surprises — just straightforward help from someone who genuinely cares.
Integrity Always
Honest, transparent advice — even if that means recommending a competitor's plan when it's better for you.
Results-Driven
Finding the best coverage at the lowest cost. We don't rest until you're properly protected.
Family First
Your family's health and peace of mind is our top priority. Every decision is made with that in mind.
Community Roots
Born and raised in Southern Indiana, deeply invested in the wellbeing of our local community.
Why Joe?
Your trusted health insurance advisor
Not Just an Agent — Your Advocate
Joe McElroy founded Family First Partners because he saw too many families struggling to navigate the confusing world of health insurance. As an independent agent based right here in Evansville, Indiana, Joe works directly with you to cut through the noise and find coverage that actually fits your life.
Independent Agent
Not tied to any single carrier. Joe shops across multiple top-rated insurance companies to find you the best deal.
Family Man
As a father and husband himself, Joe understands firsthand the importance of protecting your loved ones with the right coverage.
Community Pillar
Active member of the Evansville community. Joe believes in giving back and building lasting relationships with every client he serves.
“I treat every client like family. Because at the end of the day, that's what this is all about — making sure the people you love are protected.”
— Joe McElroy
Areas of Expertise
- Individual & Family Health Plans
- Medicare Advantage & Supplements
- Marketplace / ACA Plans
- Group Health Insurance
- Short-Term Health Coverage
- Dental & Vision Plans
- Health Savings Accounts (HSA)
- Claims & Billing Assistance
Get in Touch with Joe
Schedule a Free ConsultationLet's Find Your Perfect Plan
Family First Partners exists to serve families with clarity, integrity, and genuine care — because your health shouldn't be complicated.
Start Your Journey Today